Go Back   EcoModder Forum > EcoModding > EcoModding Central
Register Now
 Register Now
 

Reply  Post New Thread
 
Submit Tools LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 07-07-2022, 02:25 PM   #1 (permalink)
EcoModding Lurker
 
Join Date: Aug 2008
Location: Long Beach, CA
Posts: 36
Thanks: 1
Thanked 5 Times in 5 Posts
Manual vs automatic What is desirable for MPG?

Hello all,

I thought for sure I'd find a pretty good post on manual vs automatic tranies somewhere here! If there's something I missed, please let me know.

OK just to let you know, I'm a manual fan here. I am persuaded if someone can convince me that my next car should be an automatic. I tend to go for smaller and less powerful vehicles, I don't need the biggest or greatest. I always go for used vehicles too. The big thing here is that we have a good idea the trans that most desirable for MPG.

  Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to User1 For This Useful Post:
aerohead (08-04-2022)
Alt Today
Popular topics

Other popular topics in this forum...

   
Old 07-07-2022, 02:34 PM   #2 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
 
freebeard's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: northwest of normal
Posts: 27,561
Thanks: 7,736
Thanked 8,554 Times in 7,041 Posts
Quote:
I'm a manual fan here. I am persuaded if someone can convince me....
You're asking for someone to persuade you? For some reason.

I used to be a manual fan like you. I might still swap the 5-speed transaxle into my Superbeetle at some point.

But IMHO the best transmission in this day and age is the twin single-speed electric drive with differential and torque vectoring in software. Not so big on over-the-air updates.
__________________
.
.
Without freedom of speech we wouldn't know who all the idiots are. -- anonymous poster

____________________
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-07-2022, 02:52 PM   #3 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
 
aerohead's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Sanger,Texas,U.S.A.
Posts: 15,861
Thanks: 23,922
Thanked 7,207 Times in 4,640 Posts
trannies

In the past, Ricardo Engineering reported the highest efficiencies for CVT.
A 12-speed would have the equivalent efficiency.
We're up to 10-speeds presently.
BEVs with one-speed planetary gearsets have THE highest efficiencies in mpg-e.
Carmakers which claimed more efficiency for a 2-speed BEV transmission, and who produce a 2-speed BEV, have the lowest observed efficiencies of BEVs, although, perhaps not soley on account of gearing.
What's desirable is zero 'transient' loading of internal combustion engines, on account of a drift in the BSFC of the engine.
BEV's have, for all intents and purposes, a constant BSFC which is about 350% lower than an ICE.
Thermodynamically, ICE powerplants are presently the least efficient, and as motorists learn to count, are on their way out, by default.
__________________
Photobucket album: http://s1271.photobucket.com/albums/jj622/aerohead2/
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-07-2022, 09:10 PM   #4 (permalink)
Corporate imperialist
 
oil pan 4's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: NewMexico (USA)
Posts: 11,175

Sub - '84 Chevy Diesel Suburban C10
SUV
90 day: 19.5 mpg (US)

camaro - '85 Chevy Camaro Z28

Riot - '03 Kia Rio POS
Team Hyundai
90 day: 30.21 mpg (US)

Bug - '01 VW Beetle GLSturbo
90 day: 26.43 mpg (US)

Sub2500 - '86 GMC Suburban C2500
90 day: 11.95 mpg (US)

Snow flake - '11 Nissan Leaf SL
SUV
90 day: 141.63 mpg (US)
Thanks: 269
Thanked 3,522 Times in 2,796 Posts
About 3% of new vehicles sold are all electric and there's lithium battery shortages.
Internal combustion engines aren't going anywhere.
An argument can be made that fully electric are worse for the environment.
If each electric car saves about 400 gallons of gas. Sounds good right but the impact is tiny.
Let's say instead of one EV we make 6 plug in hybrids using 1 electric car worth of batteries. Now you're saving 200 to 380 gallons of gasoline times 6.
Or say instead of 5 plugins you make 30 prius like hybrids with one electric cars worth of battery, each hybrid saves up to 100 gallons of gasoline per year, times 30.
So we are far better off making prius like hybrids and keeping internal combustion engines.

Obviously hybrids are going to have automatic transmissions.
__________________
1984 chevy suburban, custom made 6.5L diesel turbocharged with a Garrett T76 and Holset HE351VE, 22:1 compression 13psi of intercooled boost.
1989 firebird mostly stock. Aside from the 6-speed manual trans, corvette gen 5 front brakes, 1LE drive shaft, 4th Gen disc brake fbody rear end.
2011 leaf SL, white, portable 240v CHAdeMO, trailer hitch, new batt as of 2014.
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-07-2022, 10:16 PM   #5 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Missoula, MT
Posts: 2,652

Dark Egg - '12 VW Touraeg
Thanks: 300
Thanked 1,176 Times in 806 Posts
While the EPA rates many automatics higher than manuals today I think that's a product of the test method. You can drive a manual more efficiently than an automatic but the EPA test cycle doesn't allow a low rpm shift on the manual while they do allow low rpm shifts on the automatic. Basically the automatic gets to do what the car knows is best, while the manual has to be shifted by some ancient book the epa put together. That's why you see lots of people here beating the EPA estimates by a bigger percentage with manuals compared to automatics.
  Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to Hersbird For This Useful Post:
freebeard (07-07-2022)
Old 07-07-2022, 11:14 PM   #6 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
 
freebeard's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: northwest of normal
Posts: 27,561
Thanks: 7,736
Thanked 8,554 Times in 7,041 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by oil pan 4
Obviously hybrids are going to have automatic transmissions.
Obviously the exception to that rule would be the gas range extender:
Quote:
https://en.wikipedia.org › wiki › Range_extender
Range extender - Wikipedia
A range extender is a fuel-based auxiliary power unit (APU) that extends the range of a battery electric vehicle by driving an electric generator that charges the vehicle's battery. This arrangement is known as a series hybrid drivetrain. The most commonly used range extenders are internal combustion engines, but fuel-cells or other engine ...
__________________
.
.
Without freedom of speech we wouldn't know who all the idiots are. -- anonymous poster

____________________
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-08-2022, 12:53 AM   #7 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
 
Blacktree's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Florida
Posts: 258

The Prius Experiment - '07 Toyota Prius Base
90 day: 58.52 mpg (US)
Thanks: 53
Thanked 167 Times in 110 Posts
Generally speaking, a manual transmission will be more efficient. That's assuming you know how to drive it efficiently.

However, the automatic transmission has undergone a paradigm shift. Many of the automatic transmissions nowadays are automated manual gearboxes, or CVTs. And the fuel economy can rival or even beat a manual transmission, depending on how you drive it.

So the answer to your question would depend on which particular transmissions you're comparing, and your driving habits.
__________________
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-08-2022, 01:21 AM   #8 (permalink)
It's all about Diesel
 
cRiPpLe_rOoStEr's Avatar
 
Join Date: Oct 2012
Location: Porto Alegre, Rio Grande do Sul, Brazil
Posts: 12,548
Thanks: 0
Thanked 1,622 Times in 1,447 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by oil pan 4 View Post
Obviously hybrids are going to have automatic transmissions.
Or even no transmission at all, relying on one of the electric motors to provide reversing, while also simulating the effect of a CVT.
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-08-2022, 03:59 PM   #9 (permalink)
EcoModding Apprentice
 
Join Date: Jun 2022
Location: Bremerton, WA
Posts: 104

Passat TDI Wagon - '97 VW Passat Wagon TDI
90 day: 55.81 mpg (US)

Blue - '21 Hyundai Sonata Blue
90 day: 53.79 mpg (US)
Thanks: 32
Thanked 57 Times in 44 Posts
I like manuals because you can quickly and safely put it in neutral in well under a second at any time by just pushing in the clutch or quickly back into gear by releasing it. If you want to maximize coasting with minimum amount of drivetrain drag, this is it.

Maybe a brand new vehicle can be this quick shifting into neutral with paddle shifters, or CVT, I don't know I have never driven one.
__________________
97 Passat TDI Wagon
Bosio 520 DLC nozzles, chip tune
Mufflerectomy
306k miles
Scan Gauge II
full belly pan
26 gallon tank
  Reply With Quote
Old 07-08-2022, 04:09 PM   #10 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
 
freebeard's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: northwest of normal
Posts: 27,561
Thanks: 7,736
Thanked 8,554 Times in 7,041 Posts
Automatics can't scan the road ahead and assess whether RPMs will be going up or down.

__________________
.
.
Without freedom of speech we wouldn't know who all the idiots are. -- anonymous poster

____________________
  Reply With Quote
The Following 2 Users Say Thank You to freebeard For This Useful Post:
RedRyder (08-03-2022), some_other_dave (08-22-2022)
Reply  Post New Thread


Thread Tools




Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.5.2
All content copyright EcoModder.com