EcoModder.com

EcoModder.com (https://ecomodder.com/forum/)
-   Aerodynamics (https://ecomodder.com/forum/aerodynamics.html)
-   -   SuperTruck: AeroCap (https://ecomodder.com/forum/showthread.php/supertruck-aerocap-25662.html)

bennelson 04-26-2013 10:17 AM

SuperTruck: AeroCap
 
Hey Guys,

I'm slowly working away on my "SuperTruck" DIY Plug-in Diesel/Electric Hybrid Pickup Truck project.

Nothing against me on the project except for time, skill, and money! :thumbup:

See the overall thought of the project at: http://ecomodder.com/forum/showthrea...uck-22080.html

I wanted to focus in the Aerodynamics forum on an aerodynamic pickup truck cap.

So here's my idea.....

So far, I've experimented with a few variations on simple/cheap tonneau covers made from recycled materials, one setup open right behind the cab for tool-box access, and most recently with a fiberglass flat cover, which turned out heavy and ugly.

What I've figured out from these exeperiments is that I do and do not have particular skills with particular materials, and other people around me with certain skill-sets.

In a nut-shell: Use what you have, Do what you know.

My Dad has been a carpenter and remodeler for his entire career. Recently, he built a cedar strip canoe. It turned out beautiful! Ended up building three of them between him and another guy.

http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...4/DSC03794.jpg
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...95-300x225.jpg
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...98-300x225.jpg

In other news, somebody locally let me know of a barn that is slated to get burned down soon as part of a local fire-fighter training exercise. The barn is less than 50 years old, but the foundation is over 100, and in disrepair. I was offered salvage rights to strip off whatever barn-boards I wanted for projects, but when I saw it, was disappointed that it's "modern" boards, instead of the classic old-timey ones. What would be a good use for these boards.

That's when I realized that they were 14 feet long each, and I remembered that part of the expense of a cedar strip canoe is getting LONG lengths of knot-free wood.

I cut a sample of one of the boards to show to my Dad. To me, it looked like Cedar, but I wasn't sure. He looked at it and told me that it was Fir, which is sort of a hard softwood, and would bend fine once cut into strips.

So here's my idea; Build a "boat-tail" aero-cap for the pickup truck using actual boat building technology, in this case the style of a cedar strip canoe, using recycled barn boards.

I can work with wood easy enough, and there are plenty of extra boards for when I do screw up. My Dad has built the wood boats before and should be a great resource for advice and help on the project. His canoe is beautiful, light, and sturdy.

Mine will be more like a less graceful upside-down row boat!

Here's an example of a wood-strip cap from Sensible Living | Spruce And Cedar Strip Canopy
http://farm7.static.flickr.com/6165/...9c6a9d298e.jpg

I'd be doing something similar, but without the ladder rack and sloping towards the rear of the truck.

Anyways, that's my idea. I have a few sketches I started doing (possibly with blind-spot windows, possibly not) and I'll have to figure out the right angle and whether or not I want a "Prius-style" back window in it.

http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...ero_marked.jpg
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...9-1024x680.jpg
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...68-300x199.jpg

Anyways, let me know your thoughts!

In other aero for the truck project, I'd be looking at a belly pan, front air dam, and rear wheels skirts - much of that most likely made from coroplast and similar light and sturdy materials.

Jyden 04-26-2013 11:01 AM

Not a bad idear. It will be light, waterproff, and dureble. Just go on with it. Bouat building tekniques are good for cars too, because the can stand the wheather.

NeilBlanchard 04-26-2013 11:19 AM

...and it will look good, and it will be made from renewable material, too.

You can model it in SketchUp and the rib former profiles can be generated an those will be accurate to the shape you design.

MetroMPG 04-26-2013 11:40 AM

Boat-building techniques for better aero - no reason not to. You'd be following in others' footsteps for sure:

http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/au.../09/dirigo.jpg
(was at http://ecomodder.com/forum/showthrea...ins-12031.html )

Rokeby 04-26-2013 12:09 PM

Classic cedar strip construction can easily achieve a smooth, sexy shape for a bed cover. While canoe, kayak and other small boat builders typically use Western Red Cedar for the base material, that is based mostly on its relative lightness and easy workability with hand and power tools due its subdued grain structure. As a bonus, western red cedar ranges in color from almost white to deep maroon and brown offering the opportunity to create custom artistic effects in the hull.

Overall weight won't be a major issue in a bed cover however, and use of any relatively knot-free soft wood should do. (Knots up to the diameter of a pencil eraser while unsightly are acceptable so long as they are not at an edge.) Fir, while acceptable, can be a real PITA due its strong grain stricture. When shaping the edges of the strips, long, thin needle-sharp splinters are easily created. These are painful at least, and when broken off can affect, the strength of strip-to-strip joints. Other softwood such as pine, spruce, hemlock -- even poplar, cypress and redwood when weight is not a major consideration and the structure will be painted -- are greatly easier to work.

Most often the individual strips are made with a "cove and bead" treatment on opposite long edges; one side curves outward, the other inward. This creates sort of a modified ball and socket-like mating surfaces. This method allows adjacent strips to be pulled tightly together going around curves for maximum glue effectiveness making for tight, strong glued up. As a secondary effect the tightness prevents "show through," light shining through thin strips of cured glue between strips in the finished hull… a sure sign of an amateur, first time building effort… but not really a strength issue if they are small and far spaced apart.

If you are really handy with a razor sharp, low angle block plane you can plane rolling. constantly changing bevels on the edges of adjacent strips so that they fit tightly together alone their full length. But this is usually the province of really experienced builders.

It is not necessary for every strip to run the full length of the structure. Typically end-to-end butt joints for the strips are acceptable if they occur one in every three strip runs and are widely spaced apart. This feature is often use to make mosaic-like artistic designs -- of even birds, fish, etc. -- in some hulls.

Coating the structure with the epoxy/'glass on the outer surface of a bed cover will be relatively easy due its convex curvature. On the inside concave surface the 'glass tends to pull away from the surface but this tendency can be over with patience and practice. Any unsightliness will not be apparent from the outside.

The cedar strip construction is covered with epoxy and fiberglass cloth which gives it the vast majority of its strength and puncture resistance. But epoxy left by itself in the sun suffers from gradual degradation due exposure to harmful ultraviolet light. This can be overcome by coating with multiple coats of a high quality varnish with UV blocker. For a structure essentially exposed to full sunlight everyday, that would be 8-10 thick coats at initial build, and at least four coats reapplied each year as the varnish gradually, imperceptibly ablates -- is burned off by the sun. On a bed cover, varnishing would be more a matter of ego than practicality. Might as well paint the structure for low maintenance.

I recommend that you visit some cedar strip building sites on the Inter-web, there are lots of them. Stay away from obvious slash and cut, quick and dirty presentations. When it comes to buying a book, Ted Moore's Canoecraft is the acknowledged bible.

http://img2.imagesbn.com/p/978155209...1_s260x420.jpg

JRMichler 04-26-2013 01:15 PM

I used wood strips for the highly curved portion of my topper lid. There was no need to twist any strips because the lid is curved in only one direction, so I did not cove them.

Clear finishes are beautiful, but high maintenance for anything that spends time in the sun.

ChazInMT 04-26-2013 01:25 PM

I know your drawings & such are all preliminary, but you may want to consider the template overlay as guidance for the top curve. Also, if you are going to leave the bed intact, you probably don't want to bring the sides in drastically as this will create 2 areas of high pressure differential in close proximity that could hijack any aero gains you would otherwise achieve.

Hope this helps.

http://i42.tinypic.com/1zq3j1y.jpg

Big Dave 04-26-2013 01:25 PM

Phil Knox (aerohead) played with using part of a real boat to make an aerolid. He may have other thoughts but IIRC it worked pretty well.

How long is your bed? If it is 80" long you'd probably need only 8 foot or 8 foot 6 inch raw strips.

I don't see why fir strips wouldn't work. Steaming the strips would help ease them into shape and reduce any tendency of the lid flying apart in the future.

A crude lid is not too tough. I made one single-handed in two days using plywood and rubber stair runner material.

But long-term, crude doesn't get it. I couldn't see out of mine and was restricted in my access to the bed. I needed a lid and sort sort of window.

If you can get help from the old canoe-builder making an aerolid with a working lids is certainly doable.

radioranger 04-26-2013 02:05 PM

always wanted to do something like that myself, recently cut a sheet of plywood to cover the back half and a few inch overhang of the tailgate, on the ranger, seemed to have picked up a solid .5 mpg gain at least, cost 22$

bennelson 04-26-2013 09:02 PM

Part of my thoughts on this is that I have seen a three-wheeler with a cedar-strip body. I think it might be the one that Metro posted.

I believe my Dad has a copy of CANOECRAFT. I'll have to see if he does, and if I can borrow it.

The truck is the short-bed version.

Today, I headed out to the Jefferson Swap Meet, a big car parts rummage sale at the County Fairgrounds the next county to the west of me. I took the side roads, and on the way out there, found an old-school junk yard and stopped. I was looking for a manual steering box for an S-10, but didn't find one.

However, there was a pair of full-moon hubcaps there, and they were 15"-ers, which was the right size for my truck. Got the pair of them for $20. Too bad they only had two. I thought I would put both on the left side of the truck, as that's what everyone sees when they are passing me anyways.

http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...19-300x225.jpg
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...33-300x225.jpg

I just post about truck aerodynamics this morning, and here I am by noon finding full-moon caps! :thumbup:

As for that barn wood I can get, here's a photo of the short sample piece I grabbed. I also split it to show off the grain. To me, it looks just like cedar, but it doesn't smell the same. It's three-inch-wide tongue and groove, and the full planks are 14 feet long.

http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...31-300x225.jpg

As for using them to make a strip-based cover, I was planning on making a "cove and bead" by getting the right router bits and use my Dad's router table.

For the finish on the cap, I would do a single-layer of fiberglass and epoxy, the same as what was done on the canoes, which has been holding up well. It's amazing how TRANSPARENT the fiberglass on the finished canoes is. It really shows off the woodwork.

Xist 04-27-2013 07:43 AM

Do you think those are the same as these: Snap-On 15 Inch Wheel Moon Cap - Speedway Motors, America's Oldest Speed Shop ? I found these, too: CCI IWCRD-15 15 Inch Clip On Stainless Steel Racing Disk Hubcaps - Pack of 4 : Amazon.com : Automotive and Set of 4 Stainless Steel 15 Inch Full Moon Racing Discs with Metal Clip Retention System - Part Number: IWCRD/15 : Amazon.com : Automotive .

Of course, the less-expensive ones do not match. Twenty dollars is a great price!

bennelson 04-27-2013 09:28 AM

They look just like the ones in the first link posted. I believe they are aluminum, not stainless.

dereck 04-27-2013 10:59 AM

i to have planed on making a strip built topper i made a plywood test one but it didnt survive the spring rains. i would make it open more like a tonno cover then with a rear door like a normal topper its hard to load large things thru small openings. here's my ply wood topper no photo on the truck unfortunately.

bennelson 04-27-2013 04:51 PM

I wouldn't do a door on the back of mine, it's more joints and complicates things.

I've experimented with magnets, which worked well. I'd be looking at doing a side-hinged magnetic setup, so that the whole cap is hinged on the drivers-side and opens on the passenger side.

That ALSO lets me get stuff all the way to the front of the bed without crawling through the back, something I don't like on my existing aluminum capper right now.

bennelson 04-27-2013 05:37 PM

Who needs CAD for pre-visualization, when you've got ratchet straps!?

Not only is it quicker and real-world, but it also has the added excitement of unexpectedly smacking me in the face. You can't say that about CAD, now can you?! :p

In all seriousness though, one fir plank, with a little tension applied, bent into a really nice looking shape, similar to an image posted earlier in this thread!

http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...4-1024x768.jpg

I stopped at my Dad's to use the table-saw, bringing over one of the barn-boards to test. We chopped it down to a more manageable length, and then ran it through the table-saw. The wood is 3/4inch thick, so we cut a rip a bit wider than an inch, then turned it sideways and ran it through to get TWO pieces wider than an inch, and about 3/8inch thick each. That looks like a reasonable size for wood strips for building with.

http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...4/IMG_0749.jpg
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...4/IMG_0750.jpg

bennelson 04-27-2013 06:12 PM

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EfxCp5-lmYA

radioranger 04-27-2013 09:49 PM

somebody here might have thoughts on front or rear placement of the hub caps, I'm guessing the front would be best.

Xist 04-27-2013 10:24 PM

I only know of two cars on here with front skirts, but you can easily do the rear, so I vote for the front.

bennelson 04-27-2013 11:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xist (Post 368546)
you can easily do the rear, so I vote for the front.

Yep, same thought. Full moons on the front and wheel skirts on the back.
For now, I put both on the left side. That's where people see them as they pass me... :snail:

freebeard 04-28-2013 02:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bennelson
I've experimented with magnets, which worked well. I'd be looking at doing a side-hinged magnetic setup, so that the whole cap is hinged on the drivers-side and opens on the passenger side.

40s Buicks and 50s International trucks had hoods that had a lever handle/hinge assembly on both sides. They opened from either side, or you could open both latches and lift it right off.

Buy in the wrecking yard, pocket the latches and sell the sheet metal as scrap. Your cap would weigh and be subject to aerodynamic forces similar to the hood, but you could always add D-rings on pins like a race car hood.

I'm collecting pieces for a boat-tail. I'm short some tubing but the skin material I have is 1/4x3 1/2" Redwood bender board. With a lower part count, I would taper the pieces to get a vacuum-bagged compound curve. The first iteration for testing will be like a model airplane fuselage skinned with pallet-wrap plastic film.

I always wanted to cut the roof off a VW Beetle and cover the rear seat, storage, and original air intake vents with a wooden, barrel-shaped tonneau cover. Single rumble seat. Parallel cream-colored pinstripes so it looks like a Chris-Craft boat. Low V-shaped windshield.

BamZipPow 04-28-2013 11:15 PM

If you look at my aero cap design/setup, my framework will allow you to have a hatch and side access doors, too! ;)

My attempt at an aero cap... - Toyota Nation Forum : Toyota Car and Truck Forums

botsapper 04-29-2013 04:02 PM

An inspiration link for your project. Don't get splinters, good luck. https://plus.google.com/photos/10505...713?banner=pwa

bennelson 05-14-2013 10:08 AM

I lost one of my full moon caps already!

The stems on my tires are pretty long. I wonder if the stem was pushing on the back of the cover and gently pushing it a bit looser every time I hit a bump?! :confused:

Anyways, a truck looks dumb enough with only TWO full moon caps on it. At least then, I can put them both on the left side. It looks REALLY stupid with just the one cap, so I took it off, and put it somewhere that it won't go flying!

I did buy a couple of $3 pizza pans from Wal-Mart (Made in America, would you believe it!) but I still need to figure how to attach them without messing up my tire balance and still be able to put air in my tires.

freebeard 05-14-2013 03:08 PM

bennelson -- Support your fellow ecomodders: First patent application was sent on 3.5.2013. It's the widget you need.

Edit: Oops—it ships in August.

bennelson 06-29-2013 10:51 AM

I had another idea about an aero-cap...

In the mind-set of "do what you know", I wonder about an aero-cap based on the design of a "teardrop trailer".

If you haven't seen one before, here's a good example.
http://300mpg.org/wp-content/uploads...62-640x480.jpg

They tend to be not as aerodynamic as they could be (a little too round, not pointy enough on the back...) but a cap based on the general design of a teardrop might work well.

Aluminum sheet is weather proof and durable, and looks pretty nice.

I built a teardrop trailer a few years back, so I already have the experience of working with wood and aluminum for something like this.

Just an idea... just throwing it out there.

freebeard 06-29-2013 01:14 PM

It's hard to imagine someone who doesn't know and love teardroppers.
http://ecomodder.com/forum/member-fr...x7-bhr-rr4.jpg

Unless you modify the pickup box to taper in plan, the top edge of the bed and the rear edge of the cab force you into a box shape anyway. Just lean the sides in to match the tumblehome of the cab.

bennelson 06-29-2013 09:24 PM

That's kinda what I was thinking. More or less a teardrop trailer, but with slanty walls.

Plus, it'd look like a Delorean!

radioranger 06-30-2013 09:14 AM

why not tow an aero trailer that matches the flow from the truck , noticed a bit of aero help towing my little boat behind the ranger

freebeard 06-30-2013 10:43 AM

radioranger -- Here's aerohead's 30-page thread on that subject.

bennelson 06-30-2013 09:36 PM

In this case, we are talking about just a cap, NOT an aero trailer. I'm just suggesting that since I have built a teardrop, maybe if I build a cap in a similar method, I'll do a good job and have something nice-looking AND effective when I'm done.

aerohead 07-10-2013 04:50 PM

Delorean
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bennelson (Post 378467)
That's kinda what I was thinking. More or less a teardrop trailer, but with slanty walls.

Plus, it'd look like a Delorean!

Put that Delorean roof profile on it and you're golden!:thumbup:

2010Sport 07-10-2013 09:12 PM

I've recently done some mods (finally) to my 2010 Ford Ranger sport v6. I put on a grill block and made some aero wheel covers. I have yet to test them head to head with the completely stock truck. I would like to your resulting mpg gain after you're done with your aero cover. If anyone would like to see some pics i will gladly take some. In other news 37 more days until i take it on a 1700mile trip to Bozeman so I can start my chemical engineering degree @ Montana State University, I can't wait!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 03:37 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.5.2
All content copyright EcoModder.com