EcoModder.com

EcoModder.com (https://ecomodder.com/forum/)
-   Hypermiling / EcoDriver's Ed (https://ecomodder.com/forum/hypermiling-ecodrivers-ed.html)
-   -   Wierd problem when P&G used extensively - '01 Civic (https://ecomodder.com/forum/showthread.php/wierd-problem-when-p-g-used-extensively-01-a-27285.html)

darcane 10-17-2013 02:52 PM

Wierd problem when P&G used extensively - '01 Civic
 
So, as I use pulse and glide more and more, an odd problem is cropping up. One stretch of my morning commute allows me to P&G a lot, to where the engine is off maybe 2/3 of the drive. Near the end of this leg, my car will randomly lose all power, no radio, no dash lights, no speedometer, ultragauge cuts out. If I put it in gear and let the clutch out, the engine will turn over... and after a second or two, fire up. After that, it will run just fine other than sometimes needing to relearn its idle.

Any ideas what is going on?

No loose wires, and I have found nothing obviously wrong. I never see this while driving "normally". I have a theory, but I wanted to fish for other ideas first.

PaleMelanesian 10-17-2013 03:40 PM

battery voltage getting too low?

RedDevil 10-17-2013 03:46 PM

Second that.
My Insight will shut the engine off when stopped (Auto-Stop) but restarts within 20 seconds or so, where it should last much longer.
I used to key off at the lights to prolong the autostop.

My new UG now shows the real reason why the engine restarts: the voltage drops below 11.6 volt, and continues to drop if I keep the engine off for too long (with lights and radio on)...

jedi_sol 10-17-2013 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RedDevil (Post 395854)
Second that.
My Insight will shut the engine off when stopped (Auto-Stop) but restarts within 20 seconds or so, where it should last much longer.
I used to key off at the lights to prolong the autostop.

My new UG now shows the real reason why the engine restarts: the voltage drops below 11.6 volt, and continues to drop if I keep the engine off for too long (with lights and radio on)...

I 3rd that. A general rule of thumb with battery voltages (car is completely off with no load on the battery at all):

Full charge 100% is 12.7volts
90% is 12.6volts
80% is 12.5volts
70% is 12.4volts
60% is 12.3volts
50% is 12.2volts
40% is 12.1volts
30% is 12.0volts
20% is 11.9volts
10% is 11.8volts
0% is 11.7volts

Check your battery voltages with a volt meter with the engine off to see where the battery voltage is at.

This is also why if you us heavy p&g...you should also switch your battery out with a deep cycle battery

Daox 10-17-2013 04:07 PM

Put up battery voltage as an ultragauge gauge and see how low you're draining that poor little battery. :)

Diesel_Dave 10-17-2013 04:26 PM

Yeah, sounds like you're getting low on battery voltage. When you really do intensive EOC P&G the issue becomes that the alternator only runs when the engine's on and the battery draw during the glide is greater than the battery charge during the pulse. This is particularly true this time of year (for those of us in the northern hemisphere). The days get shorter, so you need to drive more in the dark. That means more current draw for the lights. Colder temps also mean more current draw whenever you need to use the starter to crank the engine over.

I ran into this issue just a little last winter, and it's starting to happen again to me. Currently I average % for the engine running is about 15%. For me, it'll happen when I do a cranking start--the engine may crank a little slow, then when it starts up the ECM resets: trip meter, hr meter, FE meter, etc. all just reset. Occassionally, I've also seen the odometer lose a couple miles.

I believe Pale has also run into this issue (at least with his last car).

Here are some optons:
1) Do whatever you can to avoid cranking starts (starter use). This can be done by managing lights better , scubbing speed off and then bump starting, etc.
2) Do whatever you can to reduce current draw. Leave the radio off, HVAC blower off, etc.
3) Start using a trickle charger at least occassionally to restore the charge back up.

jedi_sol 10-17-2013 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diesel_Dave (Post 395859)
.
3) Start using a trickle charger at least occassionally to restore the charge back up.

This is what i do every night when i get home. Plus with the battery topped off...it means a little less draw on the alternator...means slightly better mpg.

PaleMelanesian 10-17-2013 04:48 PM

Yes I have had to deal with this.

LED taillights, markers, license plate.
Eco halogen headlights (10% lower power). No HID's because I'm not a jerk.
DRL disabled, but I use my LED marker lights instead for visibility.
Trickle charger overnight when it's low, but...

I just ordered a solar panel to charge it while I'm at work every day. I'll be sure to report back when I have some time with it.

RedDevil 10-17-2013 04:49 PM

I had word that Santa's Chinese elfs are carpenting a fine small solar panel for the December festivities to aid my poor battery. If it makes December. We'll see.

And only now I see PaleMelanesians post, and see what I forgot to mention; I got LED license, dome, door entry, map, city & fog lights and HIDs for the low beams since January. The rears are LED as OEM. There's not that much load on my battery.

No trickle charge, but neither the CVT nor my commute allow for much EOC P&G, so I get less chances to drain the battery. Got about 50% engine load (says UG) on even the fairest of steady 50 mph highway (long) drafts.

darcane 10-17-2013 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Diesel_Dave (Post 395859)
Yeah, sounds like you're getting low on battery voltage. When you really do intensive EOC P&G the issue becomes that the alternator only runs when the engine's on and the battery draw during the glide is greater than the battery charge during the pulse. This is particularly true this time of year (for those of us in the northern hemisphere). The days get shorter, so you need to drive more in the dark. That means more current draw for the lights. Colder temps also mean more current draw whenever you need to use the starter to crank the engine over.

I ran into this issue just a little last winter, and it's starting to happen again to me. Currently I average % for the engine running is about 15%. For me, it'll happen when I do a cranking start--the engine may crank a little slow, then when it starts up the ECM resets: trip meter, hr meter, FE meter, etc. all just reset. Occassionally, I've also seen the odometer lose a couple miles.

I believe Pale has also run into this issue (at least with his last car).

Here are some optons:
1) Do whatever you can to avoid cranking starts (starter use). This can be done by managing lights better , scubbing speed off and then bump starting, etc.
2) Do whatever you can to reduce current draw. Leave the radio off, HVAC blower off, etc.
3) Start using a trickle charger at least occassionally to restore the charge back up.

Well, my theory was that I was draining down the battery and at a certain voltage, it just cuts all power. By everyone's responses, I'd say my theory is confirmed.

I very rarely start with the key, it's almost always bump starts. I typically lead the headlights off as much as possible, but it is getting darker. I have been running with just the parking lights, I may have to look into LED bulbs as Pale suggested.

The beginning and end of my commute both have much less opportunity for P&G, so the battery tends to get more charge built up then. It's only the middle leg that I find I have trouble with it.

darcane 10-17-2013 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daox (Post 395858)
Put up battery voltage as an ultragauge gauge and see how low you're draining that poor little battery. :)

I tried... but that gauge is not offered on my UG. I have an older model, maybe it is only on the newer version.

darcane 10-17-2013 05:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jedi_sol (Post 395857)
Check your battery voltages with a volt meter with the engine off to see where the battery voltage is at.

This would be a challenge, it is only an issue while driving and if I stop, I won't be able to start it with the key...

Quote:

Originally Posted by jedi_sol (Post 395857)
This is also why if you us heavy p&g...you should also switch your battery out with a deep cycle battery

I'll look into this option, especially as winter comes along and I need headlights more often.

RedDevil 10-17-2013 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by darcane (Post 395867)
I tried... but that gauge is not offered on my UG. I have an older model, maybe it is only on the newer version.

Are you sure? I just checked, and even the Classic version has a gauge for Battery Voltage. Check your manual at UltraGauge Manuals.
(It may be so that it relies on the car ECU for providing that. The 1.2 version measures voltage on its own so it is always available.)

darcane 10-17-2013 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PaleMelanesian (Post 395862)
Yes I have had to deal with this.

LED taillights, markers, license plate.
Eco halogen headlights (10% lower power). No HID's because I'm not a jerk.
DRL disabled, but I use my LED marker lights instead for visibility.
Trickle charger overnight when it's low, but...

I just ordered a solar panel to charge it while I'm at work every day. I'll be sure to report back when I have some time with it.

Any advice for where to get LED bulbs? Superbrightleds?

jedi_sol 10-17-2013 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by darcane (Post 395868)
This would be a challenge, it is only an issue while driving and if I stop, I won't be able to start it with the key...

This wont be a challenge at all.

Assuming that the car is completely off. If you hook up a volt meter to the battery leads, you will still get a voltage.

12.7 volts = 100% charge

Therefore, assuming your battery is truly drained, if you hook up a volt meter to the battery with the car off, then your voltages will be something less than 12.7volts...maybe something along the lines of 12.0 volts.

PaleMelanesian 10-17-2013 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by darcane (Post 395870)
Any advice for where to get LED bulbs? Superbrightleds?

That's where I got mine. http://ecomodder.com/forum/showthrea...hts-25155.html

However, I was just looking on ebay and found some for cheaper. I'm getting brighter front markers for more visibility (pseudo-drl). Doing some math from SuperBright's specs, the 3528 SMD LED's put out about 6 lumens each, the 5050's put out 10. I used Sylvania's lookup page to get OEM spec lumens for my reference.

darcane 10-17-2013 06:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jedi_sol (Post 395872)
This wont be a challenge at all.

Assuming that the car is completely off. If you hook up a volt meter to the battery leads, you will still get a voltage.

12.7 volts = 100% charge

Therefore, assuming your battery is truly drained, if you hook up a volt meter to the battery with the car off, then your voltages will be something less than 12.7volts...maybe something along the lines of 12.0 volts.

The car is off... but moving at 50mph. By the time I get to my destination, it gets charged back up.

If I pull off the road, then I likely won't be able to get it started without assistance.

California98Civic 10-17-2013 06:04 PM

The Odyssey deep cycle batteries have a lot of cold cranking amps. Check them out. I use a the 1200. It has more than enough CC power for you I would be. All the specs are online.

I don't experience this problem, and I run without the alternator for 25 miles minimum daily. The battery is the key. But it's $$$.

james


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:51 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions Inc.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.5.2
All content copyright EcoModder.com