A note about Tire Rack- Make sure someone is there to pick up the delivery, otherwise you'll have to wait for the next day's deliveries. When I missed them by a half hour, I called to see if I can pick it up, and they told me the shipper (Tire Rack) doesn't allow pickups.
From those two, I'd go with the Goodyear Fuel Max. In terms of performance, it's right behind the Michelins, except the Goodyears have better wet cornering traction. You can probably get the Goodyears to match the Michelins in fuel economy when brought up to the maximum pressure.
I recently ordered and installed some
Yokohama AVID TOURING-S s from Tire Rack.