I tried that circuit yesterday, and drove it with the sound output of my laptop. The results weren't optimal - still a sine wave. Perhaps there was not enough gain in the circuit. It is also possible my laptop output was too weak.
I also tried a 741 based design I saw in a book while buying parts at the 'shack. Similar result. The schematics I see tend to be speculative, and not tested with automotive reluctors. It'd be easier if I had a scope, but even then, I'm not much of a hardware guy in regard to developing the circuit.
So I'm still not MPGuinoing