View Single Post
Old 02-28-2012, 08:38 AM   #125 (permalink)
ogregev
EcoModding Lurker
 
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: NYC
Posts: 9
Thanks: 0
Thanked 2 Times in 2 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by IamIan View Post
If one really wants to ... despite what the OEM says ... the temperature sensor they use is a relatively simple device ... it's resistance changes with temperature... so weather they make one for a 6 cell test or not ... an add on circuit could be made to do the job ... sensors for each of the 6 cells ... those sensors are feed into a comparator circuit , if any one of them or all of them collectively are above some set point the resistance the SuperBrain sees is set to high ... so instead of the SuperBrain doing it , an external circuit does it.
Unfortunately, you can't just go with an average, you need to know if any of the six thermistors triggers.

We looked into adapting the PTC circuit, but it was not sensitive enough. Its' basic settings are normal, normal, normal, about to catch fire.


Quote:
Originally Posted by IamIan View Post
You probably know the current availability better than me... I know it is an option ... but as you say availability can be an issue.

If you don't sell them anymore than that is no longer an option for people... oh well.
As of yesterday, there were two available in junkyards in all of North America (well the US and Canada). The recovery rate for sticks has dropped to an average of 5-10 per "good" pack.

Our recovery rate for trade-in packs is more like 1-2 sticks per pack, but that's heavily weighted by Civic owners who get an IMA light and do nothing about it until the next year's inspection comes. At least most Insight owners take action while the battery is still salvageable.


Quote:
Originally Posted by IamIan View Post
You know the specs of the BetterBattery ... so if it is an all or nothing thing ... than that's what it is.
A mixed pack wouldn't last a month. The SOC of the sticks would soon be very different between the old and new sticks. There's nothing wrong with either one, it would just be like putting studded snows on one side of your car and cheater slicks on the other and then trying to run a rally race in the rain.
  Reply With Quote