View Single Post
Old 03-14-2012, 11:38 PM   #129 (permalink)
shovel
Master EcoModder
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Location: Phoenix
Posts: 593
Thanks: 106
Thanked 114 Times in 72 Posts
Quote:
Originally Posted by t vago View Post
It all sounds so wonderfully simple in theory, doesn't it?
Well, kinda, yeah. Like the E85 kit I installed on my blazer a few years ago just intercepts the injector signal, extends its duration a bit, and lets the car's ECU make up the difference. Dead simple in theory, and whaddayaknow? It just plain works. I understand that DCD isn't exactly the same as enriching to compensate for an oxygenated fuel but it's not so drastically different either.

Quote:
Originally Posted by t vago View Post
Tell me something - if it's so wonderfully simple to deactivate ignition and fuel to individual cylinders, without also deactivating the associated intake and exhaust valves, then why haven't any of the major automakers done it yet? Points will be deducted for invoking conspiracy theories.
My employer manufactures a lot of electronics, and our engineers come up with all sorts of neat features we could add to them. In the end, we don't really add most of the features our engineers come up with. Sometimes we leave a feature off a $1000 product because it would add four cents to the manufacturing cost. Sometimes we leave features off because we think they might increase warranty claims due to consumer incompetence, or because there are some circumstances where that feature pushes the product too close to a failure limit. Sometimes we leave features off because we run out of time to properly test and implement them in the final revision cycle. It's not a conspiracy to make worse products, it's just how product development goes.

My guess is, the engineers who have the luxury of designing a vehicle system like cylinder deactivation at the OEM stage can design a complete system which includes the valve deactivation, and since they can, they do. If you're going to call that a conspiracy theory... well, rock on dood. I'm not here for "points"



Quote:
Originally Posted by t vago View Post
Bonus question - How will hee-hee-tech's gadget not interfere with the stock engine computer's hunting algorithm that it uses to determine whether or not the car's catalytic converter is operating properly?
Beats me, what makes you think this is impossible? The stock ECU's expecting a signal, you give it a signal, it's happy. People spoof devices and translate data all the time. I spoofed my jeep radio to think it still has a CD changer so I could hijack the cd changer input for mp3.. machines are just machines.

Quote:
Originally Posted by t vago View Post
Another bonus - Why doesn't hee-hee-tech still not have any demonstrated product, 4 years after he first announce it to the world?
Business is rough like that, where's your product? I tried to open up a coffee shop when I was 18, and now it's not in business anymore - doesn't make me an a-hole.

What's your beef, anyway?
__________________
Work From Home mod has saved more fuel than everything else put together.
  Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to shovel For This Useful Post:
Heihetech (03-15-2012)