Wow, any relation to advance auto, napa or autozone? What trucked me over was the fact someone used a 33.5mm up front on the drivers side and 37.5 for all the rest and 3 wheels.
So, when a nut was put on the 33.5mm nut and tighten up it wrapped the threads. Unless you replaced the same nut on this stud you screwed up the threads on another studd if you hammer it on and so on. I went through 2 studds and 3 nutz figuring this out. I said screw it all and ordered 30 of the 37.5 and replaced them all and bought matching nutz.
'M12-1.25 SERRATED WHEEL STUD - 12.45MM KNURL, 33.5MM LENGTH
List $4.43 ea, I can probably get them in a day or so.
M12-1.25 SERRATED WHEEL STUD - 12.45MM KNURL, 37.5MM LENGTH
List $4.79 ea, I can have 10 later today."