View Single Post
Old 07-28-2008, 03:08 PM   #8 (permalink)
EcoModding Lurker
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Ottawa, Canada
Posts: 13

Blur - '10 Kia Forte SX
Thanks: 0
Thanked 0 Times in 0 Posts
I've always used the lowest octane that my car used w/o knocking. In some cars that meant regular driving through Indiana and premium in Vest Virginia. I never noticed a chang in mpg that couldn't be attributed to terrain and/or traffic. But if it is getting you better FE I say use it until the tank before your e-check if you have one.
I agree that it could be attributed to terrain but my route doesn't really change.
Originally Posted by xbUser View Post
Don't make conclusion by filing one tank only. You get better FE, not ONLY because of switching octane. Maybe you drive on different routes, at different speed, in different mood or that pump fills your tank more than the others(so you can go further). Try at least 3 tanks. If you get 50%+ FE consistently, then keep using 89. Maybe you should try 91 later for even better FE. But, for my car, getting 40mpg with 87 makes me happy already. I don't expect it will get 60mpg by switching to 89 or 91.
Yeah I will definatly be continuing the experiment. The plan was 2 thanks 89, 2 thanks 87. But I've measured my milage before and really only get around 10-12 L / 100 KM regularly. This is why its odd to have such a dip in consuption, and the only change really seems to be the octane.

I will test it however .

Originally Posted by BlackDeuceCoupe View Post

And yet another opinion (this time my own)...

I run a high-compression, high-performance, 8200 RPM red line engine in my hypermiler. The manufacturer clearly states that this engine REQUIRES premium unleaded fuel, both in the owner's manual, and gas tank door on the donor car.

I run 87 octane...

Having said that, look at my mileage below - in the graphic!

I have run both premium and regular unleaded in this car - flea market gas and Top Tier...

Regular unleaded Top Tier gas (Shell, Chevron, Texaco etc) runs better in my ride than super unleaded non-Top Tier gas - undoubtedly because of the additives! You can do the same thing by dumping Chevron Techron (for instance) down your tank at every fill - but why bother? Gas prices are the same everywhere you go - in this market - so why spend extra on the additives, you know?

Anyway, my car starts better on regular unleaded (less cranking), runs better (more power) - but unfortunately gets identical mileage (shrug).

In my considered opinion, the only place you're going to notice a difference with higher octane gas is at startup and WFO (full-throttle)!

You're certainly NOT going to notice a difference in mileage - unless you got some underlying mechanical problem that makes your motor knock under low load and partial throttle.

In that case, fix the PROBLEM! Don't use a crutch...
But is it really a problem? A friend of mine had a 92 Acura, and it wanted 89. When he did run on 87, his efficiency went down (not noticable) but he said it was more worth it to go with 89. And again, a friend of mine with the exact same car who drives alot noticed this as well. They dont measure as closely as you guys of course.

I buy the cheapest gas around because I know as well as the next guy that its all the same dead dinosaurs, and I was even skeptical about this higher octane (I bought it cause it was on sale, it is every thursday night). I just find it odd that I show such a drastic increase with just 1 tank. I was even kinda heavy on the pedal since I had more accelerating than usual to do.

EDIT: And just an add, my engine does seem to kick a bit less than when I used 87 (and i've never used 89 before). The difference in performance as well was only in the lower end of the spectrum, I still need about 2.5k revs to keep it at 60 mph.
  Reply With Quote