Quote:
Originally Posted by aerohead
The criticism was leveled directly at the testing methodology and ignorance on the part of the investigators....Please reread my comments.I don't appreciate people putting words in my mouth.
|
No more than I appreciate people replying to posts they haven't read.
As I stated, your criticism is aimed directly at student work, where ignorance is to be expected and poor methodology the norm. You criticize the student for trying to learn. Shame on you.
In terms of your football metaphor, this paper is on the practice field. No ref's, no flags, only coaches. If the lead author were a PhD, if it were published in peer review journal, etc., that would be different.
Have fun,
Frank