Update! My car failed WV inspection due to rust. The mechanic quited $1500 but a iffy weld fix. I decided it's time for a new car.
At the moment I have 2 candidates
2014 Mirage. Stick. 42,000mi ~$6,500 after trade in
!!! 100% FINANCE SUCCESS RATE !!! 2014 Mitsubishi Mirage
2006 Scion XB. Stick. 145,000, ~$3,400 after trade
But seem nice. The trade off is more storage in the xb / better build quality but, More MPG and way lower miles in the Mirage.