[jcp123]

I had an Echo. Fantastically reliable and great mpg, but ac took a horrendous toll on FE. Echos get a plus for space versatility, nice ride, and a timing chain which basically never fails. Minuses are that it's very susceptible to wind buffeting and if you carry more than about ~150lbs besides yourself, the suspension, brakes, and power get iffy. But it's a top choice where FE and ultimate reliability are concerned. Might look and see if there's any 03-08 Corollas at that price range as well.

You might look at 96-00 Civics, although with those miles, you'll be racking up timing belt changes like crazy. Everything else will basically always just work though. It's a better driver in many ways, and comparable FE to the Echo, but not as space efficient. I got my '97 DX coupe a month and a half ago in nice shape for $2100.