View Single Post
Old 02-24-2018, 01:40 PM   #22 (permalink)
Master EcoModder
aerohead's Avatar
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Sanger,Texas,U.S.A.
Posts: 10,856
Thanks: 17,144
Thanked 5,815 Times in 3,505 Posts

Originally Posted by All Darc View Post
I know a lot was talked in this forum about ALberto Morelli's ideal aerodynamic proposal:

But this design, despite represent a 0,05 drag shape, do not consider any wheel. Aptera, based in Morelli's shape, reached 0,11 to 0,125 (varies according Aptera models) drag coefficient after add wheels, even if using streamlined covers to the wheels.

For other side the Solar Aztec car from MIT, had 0,12 drag, despite have no streamedline covers to the wheels and even a open hole in the shell near wheels:

Maybe because it was more rounded on top than Aptera, I don't know... Aptera's wheels was large, thick, and maybe it's the reason the drag raised a lot.

A third Morelli's shape car was the Solarworld No.1, but I could not find the drag coefficient for this vehicle, despite a lot of web research :

I bet Solarworld No.1 have lower drag than Aptrera and MTISolar Aztec .

But the reason I created this thread is about Ecorunner VI, with 0,048 drag coefficient already with wheels.

The earlier model, Ecorunner V, already had a drag of 0,0512 with wheels. Other vehicles with similar size and "torpedo shape style" in Shell Eco Marathon had a drag of 0,08 with wheels.
Maybe there a key point, precise calculation for aerodynamic, simulation on computer, trying to find the best shape alread with wheels (streamed covered), instead of try a shape to just later try to add wheels to it.
I just wonder what is be Ecorunner VI drag coefficient without wheel...

The hope I have it's that maybe it's possible to find a much better way to add wheel to a Morelli's basic design, and still have a drag bellow 0. or even bellow 0,91
My opinion is,that there's a bit of intellectual dishonesty with respect to the Ecorunner Cds claimed.
The caveat,is that these vehicles operate at around an average of 15-miles per hour,and due to there limited size (length),technically,they never achieved super-critical Reynolds number,and can be considered 'laminar' cars.
In 'traffic' racing with other cars in proximity,or if any crosswind existed on the track,the transverse contamination shear would force the flow to immediately transition over to a full turbulent boundary layer.If so,it would be impossible to have a Cd any lower than 0.08 according to Hucho.
Photobucket album:
  Reply With Quote
The Following User Says Thank You to aerohead For This Useful Post:
freebeard (02-24-2018)