[dremd]

Honda fit is a FANTASTIC car. Probably the "best" car I have ever owned. Way more space than you expect. Same useable space as MKIV VW Jetta wagon, current Gen Subaru Forester, or Rav 4. I had a first Gen Sport, highly recommended.

Realistically, what's your budget? Best hatch back ever I'd say Model Y Performance, but that's not realistic for many people. Best budget I LOVE my MKIV Jetta Wagon TDI with 6 speed. Most efficient, the Leaf is real hard to beat. My Model S is an absolute joy, but I have a hard time recommending one as old as mine to someone who isn't dedicated to making it work.

Edit:
I have carried 10 ft material in the Leaf many times.
Leaf is the Best second car EVER, i bought mine 4 years ago thinking it would get used occasionally due to limits, it got used for EVERYTHING except occasionally some trip it couldn't do.