View Single Post
Old 06-30-2021, 12:08 PM   #61 (permalink)
aerohead
Master EcoModder
 
aerohead's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: Sanger,Texas,U.S.A.
Posts: 16,268
Thanks: 24,393
Thanked 7,360 Times in 4,760 Posts
faster than the wind

Quote:
Originally Posted by RedDevil View Post
None of this addresses what was in the post you replied to.
But I'll reply to yours point for point. The first two hit the essence.

... it is the 'triangular sails- propeller blades' that are responsible for Blackbird's motion.

Yes, but you have to understand in what way they are responsible.

The car is moving faster than the wind, but as the propeller spins backwards the surface of the blades is moving slower than the wind.
So the wind pushes against the blades, forcing the car forward.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2) The wheels cannot power the propeller if the propeller is the sole source of power for the wheels.

The forward vector of the force on the blades powers the car forward, the sideways vector works against the gears that push the propeller against the wind. If the gearing is set so that the surface of the blades still moves forward, albeit slower than the car and of course slower than the wind, the force fighting the rotation is less than the forward pull on the blades.

The forces would be equal if the propeller would force the air backwards at the same speed as the car is moving.
The optimal setting is just slightly less than that; the friction in the system determines how much less it needs to be to function.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
3) If you examine turbine blades and propeller blades, you may find that their airfoil geometries are 'reversed.'

This is not a turbine. The propeller does not harvest energy through rotation, but through forward pull.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
4) In a bonafide powerplant failure during flight, in a variable-pitch propeller aircraft, the aircraft checklist instructs the pilot to 'de-pitch' the prop, in order
to reduce prop-drag, thereby increasing glide radius for a dead-stick landing.


A powerless plane has no surface that moves with a different speed to the wind to do anything with, what renders their propellers useless. Putting them in vane position is the only sensible thing to do in that scenario.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
5) The 'Blackbird' propeller analogy implies that, in a flight emergency, the pilot would merely 'reverse' the propeller ( like a Lockheed C-130 Hercules ), and the free-wheeling reversed propeller would now be capable of maintaining enough thrust for level flight.

Second flight analogy, but again if you have no fixed surface moving at a different speed than the wind you have no source of power.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
6) The 'masts' which hold the aircraft propeller are free to move in relation to the aircraft fuselage.

Third flight analogy. It is a flight away from the core mechanism at work.
* That the car is travelling faster than the wind has never been scientifically ascertained.
* I've provided a fluid mechanics explanation for the phenomena of the backwards-facing tattle which doesn't require the car to be exceeding the wind speed.
* And I've provided video documentation, illustrating this phenomena in action.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Any argument in favor of the veracity of Rick Cavallero's 'evidence' ought to begin with independent, 3rd-party verification of results.

*' A wise man proportions his belief to the evidence.' David Hume
* Data used cannot be influenced by hidden factors or be an artifact of the way the data were collected.
* Observational study claims are not based upon experimental study.
* The relationship must hold true in any and all studies unless there's a valid reason for it to break down under certain circumstances.

__________________
Photobucket album: http://s1271.photobucket.com/albums/jj622/aerohead2/
  Reply With Quote