View Single Post
Old 08-16-2021, 06:38 PM   #56 (permalink)
Gschuld
EcoModding Lurker
 
Join Date: Jul 2021
Location: Beachwood NJ
Posts: 39
Thanks: 4
Thanked 22 Times in 21 Posts
So I tried out my friend’s 2003 7x14 dual axle cargo trailer. 2050lbs empty with 300lbs of stuff inside. So 2350lbs. The trailer has a near flat front with about 6” radius edges on both sides and on top. The front of the cargo trailer front wall was 46” from the back bumper of my Jeep. It pulled great, but you could really feel the extra aero drag. It felt like I was pulling something 3000 lbs heavier, not 500lbs lighter. Lots of extra frontal area, nearly 30” taller than the Jeep, and 12” wider.


MPH 7x14 cargo 24’ open.
MPH. 2250lb. 2720lb.
MPH TR 1. TR 2. No TR. %drop 2. %drop 1

55. 18.3 23.2. 31.1. ——-25.4. 41.2
60. 15.7. 21.3. 27.1. ——-21.4. 42.1
65. 14.1. 20.3. 26.4. ——-23.1. 44.7
70. 13.4. 20.5. 24.9. ——-20.5. 46.2
75. 11.3. 19.6 24.1 —-—19.2. 53.2
80. 10.9. 18.2. 22.5. ——-22.5. 51.6

The difference at 75 and 80 mph is striking. 18.2mpg (with 500lbs more weight) compared to 10.9mpg at 80mph. Aero matters…..

So this tells me that if I loaded my 1400lbs of gear into that 2050lb 7x14 cargo trailer, I’d be at 3450lbs. At 75mph I averaged 11.3mpg at 2550. So add another 900lbs to it and I’d probably see around 10.5mpg at 75mph.

That same 1400lbs of gear totaling 2700lbs of custom aero considered trailer would likely beat my 2700lbs of open trailer with cinder blocks at 75mph (19.6mpg) to say 21mpg.

If so, at the target 75mph, an aero 2700lb all up trailer would get 2x the mileage at 21mpg than the 10.5mpg in an existing factory 7x14 cargo trailer at 3450lbs with the same 1400lb live load. And even better than my buddy Matt pulling a 7x14 cargo trailer at 7.5mpg at the same speed with the same 1400lb live load.
So at 21mpg and $3.15 per gallon, I’d be at $1350 in gas money for the season
At 10.5mpg and $3.15 per gallon, I’d be at $2700 in gas money for the season. A mere $1350 in savings. Naturally I’d have at least $1350 in materials to build the trailer, and a not inconsiderable amount of time to build it.

So based on this alone, I’d be far better off (in dollars and cents) borrowing the 7x14 trailer and getting 1/2 the gas mileage if considering only one seasons use.

On a side note, I pulled my open deck 24’ dual axle trailer again this morning to retrieve a large heavy rolling toolbox (28” deep, 48” tall, 7’ long). I strapped it in lengthwise centered in the trailer with lots of 2” HD ratchet straps centered the wheels fore and aft. Total weight 2760, nearly identical to my earlier test with the same trailer with lower profile cinder blocks as ballast. So same weight, same trailer, more aero drag. I was with a friend for the 1 hour trip, so I just set it at 75mph and left it. Average was 15.2mpg at 75mph, where the cinder block run was 19.6 at 75mph. 4.4 mpg worse with a little more drag on the same trailer at the same weight on the same road, because of the extra drag only.

This is all very interesting, and not far off from where I was theorizing. That’s comforting.

George

Last edited by Gschuld; 08-16-2021 at 08:04 PM..
  Reply With Quote