I got over my EV range anxiety by going with a used Chevy Volt. I was already a Hybrid owner, and looking to drop my gas usage to zero, but I was pretty timid about jumping into a full EV.
After researching many cars, I chose the Volt because it fits my personal daily driving circumstances perfectly (and the price was right): I plug it in at night and on my daily commute of 38 miles I use no gas at all, but if I decided to drive it to the Keys that's not a problem! It gets so-so gas mileage when using the ICE to power it, but those times will be few and far between