yeah, $1200-$1400 sounds about right. and like the poster above me said, 3500 miles is nothing on these bikes. hell, that thing just got broke in. i bought my 2009 model
7 months ago, and i already have over 5100 miles on it.
and the body panels aren't that expensive to replace. ever heard of ebay? you can find body panels on there for that bike really cheap.