Tire performance vs economy?

[maanma]

May be these (if they are not too narrow)
Continental AllSeasonContact 235-60-R17-102H

[JSH]

For reference the stock tires on a Gladiator that the OP says aren't aggressive enough are:

Falken WILDPEAK A/T3W in LT285/70R17




or optional Falkan WILDPEAK M/T in LT285/70R17

[GJKH]

You want to "look good". Generally means big tires with wide profile. Difficult to find and economical tire that looks good.