Those are Nokian Hakkapaliitas. If I didn't travel into the mountains, I could easily get away with all seasons, but the new house is at 7,400' (15 minutes into the foothills west of Denver) plus I get up cross country skiing at least every other weekend. So, unless I want to drive the 1998 Chevy 4x4 pick up (14-16mpg) everytime it snows, it's best just to bite the bullet and get the aggressive snow tires. Some winters they're a blessing, others, I just wonder why I mounted them at all.
The good news is my summer tires are shot, so next spring I'll be picking up some good LRR tires. The only problem I'm facing is this is still a performance car, so I need a V rated tire that's 205/55R 16. That limits my options and isn't ideal for mileage, but I'm already exceeding expectations. If I can get it consistently in the 40mpg range, I'll be thrilled. I just need two more years out of this car and I'll be replacing it with something newer that was actually designed for economy. Ironically, what I want to replace it with (early to mid-90s civic) right now costs less than the wholesale bluebook on my current car.
We'll see what comes out in the next couple years. If manufacturers start bringing over more European cars, we just might see new cars worth buying (the Toyota Yaris was one of the first, now it looks like Ford is also bringing over the Euro version of the Focus next year). Last time I was in the UK I rode in a friends 3-series BMW that had a turbo diesel that had more power than my Acura but got 51-54mpg driving like a teenager. My rental car was a Saab 9.5 wagon (estate car) TDI that got 40mpg (it was slightly larger than a Subaru Legacy wagon). Now Ford has brought the Transit van to the states, but the TDI version over there gets 45mpg and isn't available here yet. In any case, that's why I'm waiting. I'd rather buy something that has sub-150k miles on it so I can own it for a while and trust it on my mountain commute, but still want an EPA rating over 35-40mpg (without my only choice being a hybrid with a $3k+ battery that lasts 3 years or VW (which remains one option, but they're overpriced, IMHO)).