Ah I gotcha, that makes more sense.
Depending on how much you don't care about aesthetics, you can make it more aerodynamically efficient.
Aerohead and
BamZipPow are gods of pickup aeromodding.
Big Dave also made a front air dam out of a conveyor belt and saw a lot of improvement.
If you're going for a stock look or corrugated plastic isn't your cup of tea, then driving habit changes will be your only improvement.
You can read all the tips, but some of the more important ones are:
--Inflating your tires as close to the sidewall-listed maximum as you feel comfortable with (I keep mine in the 41-42 range, a good balance for me between lowered rolling resistance and comfort.)
--Driving 50-55 instead of 60-65 (I try hard not to be a headache to other drivers and sometimes sacrifice a few MPG to remain unobtrusive. Sometimes this means driving 60 in a 60.)
--Get a fuel efficiency gauge! (I dunno if the '91's had the OBDII port but if not, get an MPGuino.)
--Coast, coast, coast. Try to maximize your coasting distance in all situations. (both in-town and more importantly when taking exits on the freeway. This includes deceleration in-gear as well.)
Some or all of this may be old-hat to you, but hopefully some of it is new. Either way, welcome to the forums.
Now go spend a ton of time reading!