I like the idea of the thick weatherstripping, if the kamm stays on that will be a definite consideration.
Here is another update, I have the kamm "done" and started driving and testing it. I am not really fully done it yet, because I still haven't figured out the sealing on the side gaps, so for now I duct taped them down and am just keeping the kamm stationary.
I can honestly say that my initial results are.. meh. I did some quick coastdown testing, unfortunately it was a bit windier than I would have liked, but my schedule doesn't give me many other good oppurtunities for it. The kamm did show some slight improvement. I forgot my notes and don't have my exact figures with me, but it showed about 6% improvement, and a secent amount of error between runs (~3%). So it does seem to show a small gain, but it is difficult to judge exactly what it is.
Without the duct tape, assuming I can get a decent gap filler for the sides, it works great and exactly as I had planned as far as being able to open the trunk.
The pin system I used at the back keeps it really solid, and all I have to do is pull the two small pins and it is ready to open. (If I didn't have it sealed with tape right now).
Here is one of the pins. Just a bolt with a hole drilled through it, a nut on both sides to set the height ant tighten it on, and the pin to slide through the hole.
As for driving impressions, the gaps at the front and sides seem to seal great with just the duct tape. The kamm is very solid, and does not shift, move, flap or even wiggle in the wind which I really like. Visibility out of the rear is still great* (In dry conditions- more on that in a bit). However with the closed in sides it makes a pretty bad blind spot to the right rear of the car. It is bad enough that if the kamm stays on, I will definitely be putting my passenger side mirror back on. So I do have doubts about it, because that alone might negate any gains of the kammback.